At The Jewelry Shop, we are proud to supply all of our diamonds through GIA certified diamond suppliers. Owned and operated by Greencastle's expert jewelers Timothy Myers and Thomas Motichka, the two professionals filled the void by making The Jewelry Shop a destination for quality jewelry at affordable pricing, coupled with attentative service long after purchase. We are known as the 'Jeweler's Jeweler' since we have frequently performed repair work for neighboring jewelry stores. Not only do we provide state of the art laser welding repair services, our collections speak for themselves. We offer many designer collections inluding: Gabriel & Co. engagement rings and fashion jewelry, Lashbrook, Whitehouse Brothers and many more in store. We also offer a loose diamond directory and educational events. Since we are home to some of the best skills and repair machinery, we offer remounts, redesigns and custom engraving. Visit us online or in store today and see how much we love our craft.
The Jewelry Shop in Greencastle
11891 MOLLY PITCHER HIGHWAY , NA, NA,
The Gabriel Guarantee
We take immeasurable pride in the quality and precision of our jewelry: our free limited lifetime warranty covers any necessry repairs or replacements.
A certification number is laser- inscribed on the ring to ensure authenticity and ownership.
Get to know your ring before you buy it, by shopping with one of our experienced, family-owned and operated retail partners.
If you are not fully satisfied within 30 day, may exchange your registered item at the original purchase location for another ring of equal or higher value. Service valid for one year from purchase date.
Don’t forget to have your jewelry inspected every six months. We’re proud to offer FREE jewelry cleaning and inspection for any piece of jewelry.