Good to Have You BackKelsey Anderson’s engagement ring is making headlines again after Joey Graziadei surprised her with a second proposal during a private trip to Cabo San Lucas. But this time, it’s not just the proposal people are focusing on. It’s the ring itself.
Unlike the more traditional Bachelor-style ring Joey originally proposed during the Season 28 finale, the updated design feels far more personal. Once Kelsey shared photos online, fans immediately started zooming in on the details, especially the unusual combination of a pear-shaped diamond and vivid green side accents.
The result feels less like reality TV and more individual to them as a couple.
The relationship
Joey Graziadei and Kelsey Anderson met during Season 28 of The Bachelor, where Graziadei appeared as the lead after previously competing on The Bachelorette. Anderson quickly became one of the strongest connections of the season, and their relationship continued growing throughout filming before Joey proposed during the finale in Tulum, Mexico.
Unlike many reality TV couples whose relationships lose momentum once the cameras disappear, the two remained together after the show and have continued building their relationship publicly while planning their future together.
Joey Graziadei proposal to Kelsey
Joey Graziadei first proposed in 2024 during The Bachelor finale with a Neil Lane engagement ring centered around an emerald-cut diamond.
More recently, in May 2026, he proposed to Anderson again during a private trip to Cabo San Lucas. The second proposal was intentionally more personal and away from television production, allowing the moment to feel more connected to their real relationship outside the show.
The couple later shared the proposal photos online with the caption “She said yes (again),” immediately drawing attention to the completely new ring design.
Kelsey Anderson’s engagement ring
The Bachelor engagement ring
Kelsey Anderson’s original engagement ring followed a more classic Bachelor engagement ring formula. Designed by Neil Lane, it featured a three stone setting with an emerald-cut diamond flanked by two shield-shaped side stones on a diamond-accented platinum band.
Browse our collection of emerald cut engagement rings for similar styles.
The New Ring
The newer ring takes a very different direction.
Based on the images shared online, the updated design appears to feature a three-stone pear shaped engagement ring with vivid green side stones set on a yellow gold band. The green accents introduce a strong Art Deco influence, giving the ring a more vintage-inspired and architectural feel compared to the cleaner look of the original ring.
The pear-shaped center stone softens the structure slightly, while the colored side stones create contrast and immediately draw the eye. Together, the combination feels more expressive and less traditional than the ring viewers first associated with the couple during The Bachelor finale.
It’s a design that feels intentionally different from the original.
Less tied to television expectations and more reflective of personal style.
If you’re into the Art Deco aesthetics, explore our vintage-inspired engagement rings and find the piece you’ll cherish forever.
Inspired by Kelsey, signed Gabriel & Co.
Kelsey Anderson’s ring style stands out because it mixes classic bridal elements with stronger vintage-inspired details. The pear-shaped center stone keeps the design soft and romantic, while the yellow gold and side accents bring in more structure and personality.
Here are two engagement rings from our collection that capture a similar feeling.
The first ring pairs a pear-shaped center diamond with smaller pear side stones and additional round accents along the band. The layered silhouette gives the ring more dimension while still keeping the focus on the elongated center stone.
The second design takes a slightly cleaner direction with round side stones framing the pear-shaped diamond. The yellow gold setting and three-stone structure echo the warmth and balanced proportions seen in Kelsey’s ring while creating a softer overall look.
FAQs
Who is Kelsey Anderson engaged to?
Kelsey Anderson is engaged to Joey Graziadei, the lead from Season 28 of The Bachelor.
Did Joey Graziadei propose to Kelsey Anderson twice?
Yes. Joey Graziadei first proposed during The Bachelor finale and later proposed again during a private trip to Cabo San Lucas.
What did Kelsey Anderson’s first engagement ring look like?
Her first ring featured an emerald-cut diamond with shield-shaped side stones on a platinum diamond-accented band designed by Neil Lane.
What does Kelsey Anderson’s new engagement ring look like?
The updated ring appears to feature a pear-shaped center diamond with green side stones set on a yellow gold band.
What style is Kelsey Anderson’s new engagement ring?
The ring has strong Art Deco influences, combining geometric structure, colored side stones, and a vintage-inspired look.
Why is Kelsey Anderson’s engagement ring trending again?
The ring gained attention after Joey Graziadei surprised Anderson with a second proposal and a completely new ring during their trip to Cabo San Lucas.
What diamond shape is Kelsey Anderson’s new ring?
The center stone appears to be pear-shaped based on the images currently available online.
Why are Art Deco engagement rings becoming popular again?
Art Deco rings are gaining attention again because of their structured silhouettes, vintage influences, and use of details like colored gemstones and geometric settings.
With 2025’s celebrity engagement rings setting the tone, we can’t help but look ahead to the moments and engagement ring trends that will define 2026.
